Everyone’s heard about Chris Brown’s dramatic “breakdown” while singing a medley of Michael Jackson’s songs during the BET Awards on Sunday. He couldn’t get through “Man in the Mirror” and started openly weeping on stage. There’s a lot of debate about how legit the performance was, but the man who beat Rihanna just a little over a year ago has garnered a surprising amount of public empathy for his display of emotion.

Jimmy Kimmel, for one, isn’t buying it.